Lady Hale gave a judgment concurring in the result, with which Lord Wilson agreed, though added a qualification to Lord Sumption's decision.
22.
), p . 215; Sumption ( 1990 ), p . 530 Geoffrey le Baker gives around 300 English soldiers killed at a highest estimate.
23.
Lord Sumption was concerned about the position where : " there are multiple purposes, all influential in different degrees but some proper and others not ".
24.
Jonathan Sumption, Straw's attorney, said the home secretary wanted to reconsider the extradition request " with a blank sheet of paper ."
25.
Lord Sumption has been elected a Fellow of the Royal Historical Society ( FRHistS ) and a Fellow of the Society of Antiquaries of London ( FSA ).
26.
On the 18 February 1993, Kennedy LJ, upheld the High Court, with Andrew Burrows acting for Islington LBC, and Jonathan Sumption QC for Westdeutsche.
27.
The queen's lawyer, Jonathan Sumption, said the articles were a " highly objectionable invasion of privacy, devoid of any legitimate interest ."
28.
Jonathon Sumption also records that casualties may have been 300 civilians, " perhaps a sixth of the normal population, ", plus 60 members of the garrison.
29.
Lady Hale and Lord Toulson would have exercised jurisdiction in this case; Lord Sumption and Lord Clarke would not have done; and Lord Wilson left the question open.
30.
But if Straw decides not to issue a new decision, he would effectively be rejecting the Spanish request, inviting the court to quash his first ruling, Sumption said.
