This Discussion also mentions " Six ( 6 ) Comments " by Radar chart users about many more limitations ( that was deleted by a non-technical Reviewing Editor, which I believe should be reinstated to give the article several additional creditable sources .)
32.
I'm shocked that Glrx could not be persuaded by the impartial comparisons made in the SG chart article and while he may know about the effects of Geometry on the Radar chart, saying that those faults directly carry over to a SG chart, IS TOTALLY UNTRUE!
33.
Chester's claims at Talk : SpiderGraph chart # Objection to Deletion and Response to Reviewing Editor's Concerns are not persuasive, and they fail to understand the axis-order and linear / sqrt scaling problems of the radar chart ( and how those faults directly carry over to a SpiderGraph ).
34.
Unfortunately, it was also learned that many of its users were dissatisified with the Excel Radar charting method, which uses estimation as a way to make decisions ! "'( Refer to the deleted Section of the SpiderGraph chart article " Six Comments Regarding Limitations of the Radar chart . " ) "'
35.
The SpiderGraph charting method and the computer-driven Radar charting method are two totally different charting methods that arrive at a Trade-off Decision differently, " the SG chart by calculation " and " the Radar chart by estimation ! " ( I'm sure you can guess which one is more accurate !)
36.
The only assertion that the SG chart article " proves " is that there is no computer needed to draw the chart, which causes the limitations in the Radar charting method, therefore it is more accurate because the user can calculate the Trade-off Decision directly and not have to estimate it like the Radar chart requires!
37.
The Examining Attorney suggested that an article or definition suggesting that there's a difference between Radar spider charts and SpiderGraph charts, be published to cut down on confusion and future infringements . "'( at that time, the Author used only the WP : Radar chart article as a reference for the impartial comparisons throughout the article!
38.
You mentioned that your aim is to enhance WP and make it better, well with only one choice, the Radar chart estimation method presently to make Trade-off decisions, that users are very unhappy with; giving WP a second and more accurate choice, like the SG chart article, may just be the way to do that.
39.
Chester's legal claims " deal only with the word SpiderGraph " ( that fact has been intentionally omitted from the article ) and belongs to a special and totally different charting method and has nothing whatsoever to do with, or referring to, a radar " graph ? ", which BTW, heretofore has always been referred to as a Radar chart or Radar spider chart!
40.
The combined data show that, in one instant, a patch of the fuselage blew out, the airplane lost all electrical power, and the jet was shoved sharply left, shifting half a mile out of its original flight path while the ejected material fell southeast toward the sea, said John P . Fish, a private underwater search consultant who worked on preliminary radar charts of the wreckage.
